How useful is Mediation to HR Departments?

July 9, 2023

1. Introduction to Mediation in HR Departments

1.1 Definition and Purpose of Mediation

1.2 Importance of Mediation in HR

In today's dynamic workplace, conflicts and disputes are inevitable. As a result, Human Resources (HR) departments play a crucial role in managing and resolving these issues, ensuring a harmonious and productive work environment. One approach that has gained significant recognition in recent years is mediation. Mediation is a voluntary and confidential process in which a neutral third party facilitates communication, understanding, and resolution between conflicting parties. In the context of HR departments, mediation serves as a valuable tool for resolving conflicts, improving employee relations, and fostering a positive organisational culture. This article explores the usefulness of mediation in HR departments, delving into its benefits, challenges, implementation steps, and future opportunities. By understanding the role of mediation, HR professionals can harness its potential to effectively address workplace conflicts and achieve sustainable resolutions.

1. Introduction to Mediation in HR Departments

1.1 Definition and Purpose of Mediation

Mediation is a voluntary and confidential process where a neutral mediator helps employees and employers find common ground and resolve conflicts. The purpose of mediation is to promote understanding, find mutually agreeable solutions, and maintain a harmonious work environment.

1.2 Importance of Mediation in HR

Let's face it, conflicts happen in every workplace. HR departments often find themselves caught in the crossfire, juggling grievances and trying to keep the peace.  Mediation provides a structured approach that allows HR professionals to address conflicts effectively and prevent small sparks from turning into raging infernos.

2. Benefits of Mediation for HR Conflict Resolution

2.1 Facilitation of Open Communication

Mediation breaks down the barriers of communication, allowing individuals to express their concerns, frustrations, and viewpoints in a safe and controlled environment. It's like providing a megaphone for each party to be heard, ensuring that all vital information is aired out and considered.

2.2 Preservation of Workplace Relationships

It focuses on finding common ground and understanding, allowing employees to preserve their relationships and move forward collaboratively. Because let's be honest, a harmonious workplace is much more enjoyable than one filled with grudges and tension.

2.3 Cost and Time Efficiency

From a practical standpoint, mediation can save HR departments valuable resources. By resolving conflicts in a timely manner, mediation saves both time and money that would otherwise be spent on lengthy investigations or legal battles. It's like finding a shortcut to conflict resolution without compromising on fairness or thoroughness.

3. Role of Mediation in Improving Employee Relations

3.1 Encouraging Collaboration and Cooperation

Mediation encourages employees to work together towards a resolution. It shifts the focus from "me versus you" to "us against the problem." By fostering collaboration and cooperation, mediation helps build a culture of teamwork and unity, creating an environment where everyone can thrive.

3.2 Enhancing Employee Engagement and Satisfaction

Happy employees make for a happier workplace. Mediation plays a significant role in improving employee engagement and satisfaction. By addressing conflicts swiftly and fairly, mediation helps employees feel heard, validated, and invested in the organisation's success.

4. Steps Involved in Implementing Mediation in HR Processes

4.1 Identifying Appropriate Cases for Mediation

Not every conflict may be suitable for mediation, so it's crucial to identify cases where mediation can be effective. This involves assessing the nature and context of the conflict, considering the willingness of parties to participate, and ensuring confidentiality can be maintained.

5. Resistance to Mediation

5.1 Resistance to Mediation from Employees or Management

Mediation might seem like the golden solution to resolving conflicts in the workplace, but it's not always smooth sailing.

One of the challenges that HR departments may face is resistance from either employees or management. Some individuals may be skeptical about the effectiveness of mediation or simply refuse to participate altogether. In such cases, HR professionals need to find alternative approaches to address the underlying issues and ensure a fair resolution.

HR might want to point to the Acas report supporting the use of mediation in the workforce. They might wish to flag the potential cost in time and resources to HR or management in the loss of employee productivity, the lack progression of organisations plans, the potential escalation of the dispute to a formal grievance, staff retention difficulties, reputational consequences to staff, HR, and the organisation, and potential employment tribunal proceedings.

Mediation can be implemented quickly, staff feel heard and that HR and Management are effectively dealing with their concerns, it can enable better communication between staff and teams, assisting to restore valuable relationships, thus preserving teams. Staff often do not want to leave their positions but without an effective mechanism to manage workplace conflict they sometimes feel that they have no option. 

5.2 Confidentiality and Privacy Concerns

Confidentiality is a crucial aspect of mediation, allowing participants to speak openly without fear of repercussions. However, in HR departments, confidentiality can sometimes clash with the need for transparency and documentation. Balancing these two concerns can be a delicate dance, as HR professionals must navigate privacy regulations while keeping the necessary records to protect the organisation. Implementing clear guidelines and ensuring the confidentiality of mediation proceedings is essential to overcome this limitation.

5.3 Lack of Mediation Skills and Expertise within HR

While HR professionals are skilled in many areas, mediation might not be their primary expertise. Mediation requires a unique set of skills, such as active listening, impartiality, and problem-solving abilities. HR departments might face limitations in effectively mediating conflicts due the perception that they are protecting the organisation.

6. Fictional Case Studies: Successful Applications of Mediation in HR

6.1 Fictional Case Study 1: Resolving Interpersonal Conflict

In a manufacturing company, two employees, John and Sarah, were constantly at odds, affecting team productivity and morale. The HR department could implement mediation by, bringing in a neutral mediator to facilitate communication between John and Sarah. Through mediation sessions, the underlying issues could be identified, and a resolution could be reached, enabling the two employees to work together more effectively and improve team dynamics.

6.2 Fictional Case Study 2: Mediating Team Disputes

In a marketing agency, two teams are in a long-standing rivalry, leading to hostile competition and a toxic work environment. HR organise a mediation session with representatives from both teams to address their concerns and find common ground. The mediator could facilitate open dialogue, helping the teams understand each other's perspectives and foster collaboration. This could result in improved teamwork, increased productivity, and a more positive work culture.

6.3 Fictional Case Study 3: Addressing Performance-related Issues

A sales executive, Mark, consistently failed to meet his targets, causing tension within the team. Instead of resorting to disciplinary action, the HR department could opt for mediation. The mediator could work with Mark to identify the root causes of his underperformance and assist in developing an action plan to improve his performance. Through ongoing mediation sessions, Mark could receive support, guidance, and accountability, leading to a significant improvement in his sales performance.


1. What is the role of mediation in HR departments?

Mediation plays a crucial role in HR departments by offering a structured and neutral process for resolving conflicts between employees. It facilitates open communication, preserves relationships, and helps improve employee relations, ultimately fostering a positive and productive work environment.

2. How does mediation benefit HR conflict resolution?

Mediation brings several benefits to HR conflict resolution. It provides a safe space for parties to express their concerns, helps identify underlying issues, and promotes mutual understanding and collaborative problem-solving. Mediation is also time and cost-efficient compared to traditional adversarial methods, and it allows HR professionals to maintain control over the outcome.

3. Can mediation be used for all types of conflicts in HR?

While mediation is effective for many types of conflicts, it may not be suitable for all situations. Some conflicts, such as those involving harassment, discrimination, or illegal activities, may require a different approach, involving more formal investigations or legal procedures. However, for interpersonal disputes, communication breakdowns, or team conflicts, mediation can be a highly useful and effective resolution method.

Positive about your Future
“Never cut what you can untie.” - Joseph Joubert
Start Now